In a guest post for Jane Friedman, Karmen H. Špiljak explains that her own writing style has always blended planning and improvisation, a hybrid she calls a “plantser.” She says that the term was unsatisfying because it did not help her understand her process or improve it.
Špiljak’s breakthrough came after reading Anne H. Janzer’s book The Writer’s Process: Getting Your Brain in Gear, which divides writing into seven steps, from research to publication. The author condenses these into three phases—preparation, drafting and revision—and shows that the plotter‑pantser divide rests only on the first phase.
Preparation, she notes, is far more than outlining. It can include rough outlines, character notes, discovery scenes, mood boards or even mental rehearsals. “Equating preparation with outlining underestimates the sheer amount of work that goes into crafting a story,” she writes.
Špiljak compares preparation to swimming: some writers jump straight in, while others splash water first. She argues that labeling writers as plotters or pantsers diverts attention from the process itself and can lead to unnecessary judgment.
Instead, she encourages writers to experiment with a variety of preparation tools—notes, outlines, scene‑by‑scene plans—and to choose what works best for each project. This flexible approach, she says, removes shame and allows writers to keep their process fresh and responsive to each story’s needs.